Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
PSYCHOPATHY & THE LIMITS OF T.F.P
  • Michael H Stone, MD


  • Prof. Clin. Psychiatry: Columbia
2
Psychopathy: Overall Picture
3
ANTISOCIAL P.D. in DSM-4
[in contrast to Psychopathy]
  • Failure to conform to social norms
  • Deceitfulness [lying, conning, aliases]
  • Impulsivity: failure to plan ahead
  • Reckless disregard for safety of others
  • Irritability;  aggressiveness
  • Irresponsibility
  • Lack of remorse
  •              [3 or > of the above]
4
HARE’S PSYCHOPATHY CHECKLIST
“revised”:  PCL-R [1991]
  • CONSISTS OF 20 ITEMS, scored via interview & historical data: 0, 1, or 2
  • Total Score: Maximum of 40
  • Score of 30 or > [25 or > in Europe] makes the diagnosis
  • Developed for forensic use, but now used in other contexts as well
  • Can be used for adolescents also
5
HARE’S “FACTOR-1”
[the narcissistic personality factor]
  • GLIBNESS;  SUPERFICIAL CHARM
  • GRANDIOSE SENSE OF SELF-WORTH
  • PATHOLOGICAL LYING
  • CONNING;  MANIPULATIVENESS
  • LACK OF REMORSE OR GUILT
  • SHALLOW AFFECT
  • CALLOUSNESS
  • FAILURE TO ACCEPT [COGNITIVELY] RESPONSIBILITY FOR ONE’S ACTIONS
6
HARE’S FACTOR-2:
the impulsivity factor
  • EXCESS NEED FOR STIMULATION
  • PARASITIC LIFE-STYLE
  • POOR BEHAVIORAL CONTROLS
  • EARLY BEHAVIORAL PROBLEMS
  • LACK OF REALISTIC LONG-TERM GOALS
  • IMPULSIVITY
  • IRRESPONSIBILITY
  • JUVENILE DELINQUENCY
  • FAILURE OF PAROLE
7
Additional Items of the PCL-R that do not map onto Factors #1 or #2
  • Promiscuous Sexual Behavior
  • Many Short-Term or “De Facto” Relationships
  • Criminal “Versatility” [by which is meant – a multiplicity of different types of criminal offenses]
8
CRIMINAL VERSATILITY:
The Main Categories
  • Theft
  • Drug Offenses
  • Murder
  • Weapons Possession
  • Major Auto Offenses
  • Kidnapping
  • Treason
  • Obstruction of Justice
  • Robbery
  • Assault
  • Fraud
  • Sex Offenses
  • Escape
  • Arson
  • Miscellaneous [viz., vandalsim]
9
DAVID COOKE’S RE-FACTORING OF THE PSYCHOPATHY CHECKLIST
  • THE PERSONALITY FACTOR
  • 1. Glibness
  • 2. Grandiosity
  • 3. Lying
  • 4. Conning; Manipulativeness
  • [an arrogant, deceitful personality]
10
DAVID COOKE’S RE-FACTORING OF THE PCL-R, cont’d
  • THE AFFECT FACTOR
  • 1. Shallow Affect
  • 2. Callousness
  • 3. Lack of Guilt
  • 4. “Not Responsible”
  • [deficient affective experience]
11
COOKE’S REFACTORING OF THE PCL-R, cont’d
  • THE BEHAVIOR FACTOR
  • 1. Easily Bored; Novelty Seeking
  • 2. Impulsivity
  • 3. Irresponsible Behavior
  • 4. Parasitic Life-Style
  • 5. No Reasonable Long-Term Goals
  • [impulsive/irresponsible behavior]
12
“INSTRUMENTAL VIOLENCE”
13
Biological Factors in Psychopathy
14
BRAIN CORRELATES OF AGGRESSIVE PSYCHOPATHY
  • Non-Specific EEG Abnormalities
  • Resistance to Aversive Conditioning [similar to Cloninger’s LOW HARM AVOIDANCE
  • LO Levels of 5-HIAA in CSF of adult psychopaths
  • Neurologic Soft Signs
15
A SPECTRUM OF NARCISSISTIC DISORDERS
16
THE RANGE OF T.F.P. in relation to the NARCISSISTIC SPECTRUM
17
SOME CLINICAL EXAMPLES
  • Narcissistic Traits
  • NPD [DSM criteria]
  • Malign.Narcissism
  • Some ASPD Traits
  • ASPD [DSM-IV]
  • PCL-R 15-25
  • PCL-R > 29
  • Young Boxer
  • Surgical Resident
  • Company CEO
  • Stalker/boyfriend
  • Cocaine Addict
  • Minister’s D’ghter
  • Prodigal Son
18
Borderline Features: Severe Splitting
in the not-fully psychopathic cases
19
What to Do with the Hot Potato???
[dealing with intense psychic pain]
20
Some Relevant Dynamics in the Less-than-fully Psychopathic Cases